National Library of Australia

You must be logged in to Tag Records
Student Research [microform] : Productive or Counterproductive? / Joy McGregor
Bib ID 5612341
Format BookBook, MicroformMicroform, OnlineOnline
McGregor, Joy
Online Versions
Description [S.l.] : Distributed by ERIC Clearinghouse, 1996 
9 p. 

This paper describes two studies conducted with high school students doing library research and writing research papers, with the objective of examining the effectiveness of this type of assignment. The students were all in grade 11, the first group in Canada, the second in the United States. Students were observed in the classroom before they received their research paper assignments, in the library while searching for information, and while they wrote their papers. Formal and informal interviews were conducted, and their notes, rough and final drafts and original sources were examined. Both productive and counterproductive elements of the assignments were identified. The teacher's guidance throughout the process was appreciated by most students; students liked having the process broken down into manageable steps, which they found less intimidating than being given the whole task to do on their own. The teacher brought some of the needed reference books into the classroom and drew a map of the library to help students find materials. Examples provided in handouts made writing a thesis statement and an outline easy. Suggesting that students did not have to write their rough draft in order also seemed to help. The first study revealed a great deal of plagiarism. Students objected to: copying directly from sources onto note cards; rewriting of their thesis statements by the teacher, for those who were struggling; and the unavailability of computer lab time for word processing. Another counterproductive behavior come from an incomplete mental mode of the potential role of a school librarian. This study concludes that school librarians, in cooperation with teachers, must make every library research project meaningful to students. (AEF)


ERIC Note: Paper presented to the International Association of School Librarianship Conference (July-August, 1996).

May also be available online. Address as at 14/8/18:

Reproduction Microfiche. [Washington D.C.]: ERIC Clearinghouse microfiches : positive. 
Subjects Assignments.  |  Foreign Countries.  |  Grade 11.  |  High School Students.  |  High Schools.  |  Information Seeking.  |  Librarian Teacher Cooperation.  |  Library Instruction.  |  Student Projects.  |  Student Research.  |  Teaching Methods.  |  Writing (Composition)  |  Canada United States
Form/genre Reports, Evaluative.  |  Speeches/Meeting Papers.
Available From ERIC 


In the Library

Request this item to view in the Library's reading rooms using your library card. To learn more about how to request items watch this short online video Help Video.

Details Collect From
mc 2253 ED414906 Main Reading Room - Newspapers and Family History
This item may be online. Please search the ERIC website prior to requesting this microfiche item.

Order a copy

- Copyright or permission restrictions may apply. We will contact you if necessary.

Help Video To learn more about Copies Direct watch this short online video Help Video.
close Can I borrow items from the Library?

You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video embedded.

You can view this on the NLA website.

close What can I get online?

You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video embedded.

You can view this on the NLA website.

close Can I get copies of items from the Library?

You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video embedded.

You can view this on the NLA website.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Flags
Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander and other First Nations people are advised that this catalogue contains names, recordings and images of deceased people and other content that may be culturally sensitive. Please also be aware that you may see certain words or descriptions in this catalogue which reflect the author’s attitude or that of the period in which the item was created and may now be considered offensive.